Thanks for this. One comment from me (as a long term British Germany-watcher): I don’t actually think (most) easteners really think that life was better under the GDR, I think that life was ‘known’, and that makes them feel like it was better, because so much about the future is unknown now. I think the fear of losing everything again sits very deep. In other news, I find it SO frustrating to see these ‘peace’ protests marching under a motto of peace. But it’s also getting us nowhere simply to accuse them of being Putinversteher. I don’t know how to bring nuance back into the discourse. I don’t even know if it’s even possible at this stage.
We had a really interesting talk about this at Hertie School last week, between two Enderlein Fellows, and outgoing one from Latvia and an ingoing one from Moldova. We came to the conclusion people felt they had more dignity under the old system even if the had less stuff. Which means they felt less far behind their neighbours economically, which apparently matters more than what you have absolutely. Also, this feeling of being failed by your government leads to security challenges as you can be persuaded to work against them, often benefiting someone else's.
On Saturday on Greifswalder str. there was a group of young men in 3 old trabi cars, roaring and cheering, holding aloft the East German flag. I honestly couldn't tell whether it was a joke or not.
Only lived in berlin for twelve years trying to step out of bubbles and heard from many born in the 70s and before that unity was mismanaged, creating a massive gap between the haves and have nots and that at least gdr was economic certainty of a comfy level. The relentless force of the west to dominate was never forgotten and some attribute the discontent of the easterners to the rise of the Alternative. Some consistencies when you look at the map of afd stronghold.
"Wenn wir zum Krieg rüsten, werden wir Krieg haben" Brecht. ( Seen on a demo poster. foto from demo ). Not so dumb to have a peace demo on Okt.3, given that the memory holes are getting so deep! Can't measure how overboard the Putin fandom was, wasn't there. Could say alot more on that, but will have to keep it short.
Thanks for this. One comment from me (as a long term British Germany-watcher): I don’t actually think (most) easteners really think that life was better under the GDR, I think that life was ‘known’, and that makes them feel like it was better, because so much about the future is unknown now. I think the fear of losing everything again sits very deep. In other news, I find it SO frustrating to see these ‘peace’ protests marching under a motto of peace. But it’s also getting us nowhere simply to accuse them of being Putinversteher. I don’t know how to bring nuance back into the discourse. I don’t even know if it’s even possible at this stage.
We had a really interesting talk about this at Hertie School last week, between two Enderlein Fellows, and outgoing one from Latvia and an ingoing one from Moldova. We came to the conclusion people felt they had more dignity under the old system even if the had less stuff. Which means they felt less far behind their neighbours economically, which apparently matters more than what you have absolutely. Also, this feeling of being failed by your government leads to security challenges as you can be persuaded to work against them, often benefiting someone else's.
https://www.hertie-school.org/en/international-security/news/detail/content/hertie-school-hosts-fifth-henrik-enderlein-fellowship-lecture
Thanks, Joanna. We need more public discourse on this.
There is a joke that I really like.
I don’t remember the exact text, but it goes smth like:
A very old Russian man has been asked about Stalin.
- Stalin was awesome!
- How come? He had millions of people killed.
- Because at the times of Stalin I was 18 and had many girlfriends.
On Saturday on Greifswalder str. there was a group of young men in 3 old trabi cars, roaring and cheering, holding aloft the East German flag. I honestly couldn't tell whether it was a joke or not.
Only lived in berlin for twelve years trying to step out of bubbles and heard from many born in the 70s and before that unity was mismanaged, creating a massive gap between the haves and have nots and that at least gdr was economic certainty of a comfy level. The relentless force of the west to dominate was never forgotten and some attribute the discontent of the easterners to the rise of the Alternative. Some consistencies when you look at the map of afd stronghold.
"Wenn wir zum Krieg rüsten, werden wir Krieg haben" Brecht. ( Seen on a demo poster. foto from demo ). Not so dumb to have a peace demo on Okt.3, given that the memory holes are getting so deep! Can't measure how overboard the Putin fandom was, wasn't there. Could say alot more on that, but will have to keep it short.