Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Audrey's avatar

On the topic of the Tesla protests:

I'm really not a fan of the logic that because there are worse things elsewhere, that people shouldn't protest something that is genuinely shitty. Yes, I would love to see actions happen against the traditional car companies too. But should be an *and* not an *or*.

Some reasons to fight Tesla's expansion are broad, and not Tesla-specific. For example, we need to be moving away from car infrastructure in general and putting more focus on public transit, biking and walking. The production of electric vehicles uses up resources like lithium, which are extracted in ways that are absolutely horrific for the people who do the work, while also badly damaging those environments. This extraction and destruction is worth fighting against. Electric vehicles are certainly *part* of how we navigate the climate crisis, but the way they're being made now is a fucking problem. And it also does not make sense to continue the destructive pattern of individualized transport in big, heavy, dangerous vehicles.

To get to the specifics though, about why Tesla, why this factory, why now... There is an immediate and urgent threat to the water supply and to the forest. At the same time that there's talk of rationing water for personal use, Tesla is trying to greatly expand its water-use. If Musk and Tesla's past behavior is any indication of future plans, they will do this regardless of whatever rules (if any) exist for them. If the forest is lost, and the water use of Tesla is expanded, it will be very hard or impossible to reverse the damage.

So yeah... fuck every car factory and company in Germany. None of them are behaving correctly given our current context, and all of them are a legitimate target of rage. But we have one in particular, very close by, that is about to cause significant and irreversible damage. I support the forest occupiers.

If you'd rather see action against the other car companies, go right ahead! Use your platform to rip them apart. But stop shitting on people who you say you're "sympathetic" to. You can help, or you can get out of the way.

Expand full comment
Cesar Bretana's avatar

That guy wondering whether it’s necessary to shower every day is not riding the U8 every day to work, clearly.

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts